Old World Craftsmanship Meets Modern Living

526 Carlton Avenue is a beautifully preserved five-bedroom, 2.5-bath, 3,600-square-foot limestone townhouse built in 1877 and recognized by the Landmarks Preservation Commission as the best-preserved home on the block. Flooded with sunlight thanks to its rare east-west orientation, this centrally located Prospect Heights gem offers unparalleled urban convenience.

The location is exceptional: Citi Bike stations sit on the corner, Brooklyn Clay, Studio Pilates, across the street,  dog parks, playgrounds, Chelsea Piers, parking garage  are around the block . Vibrant Vanderbilt Avenue—with its acclaimed restaurants and shops—is just one block away. Barclays Center and Atlantic Terminal, providing access to 11 subway lines and the LIRR, are only a few blocks from your door.

A unique amenity sets this block apart: a doorman building directly across the street accepts packages for neighbors, solving one of townhouse living’s most common challenges. With its combination of historic character, natural light, generous space, and modern convenience, 526 Carlton Avenue represents a rare opportunity in one of Brooklyn’s most desirable neighborhoods.

Inside, original 19th-century details—including high ceilings with plaster medallions, pier mirrors, wainscoted window casings with original shutters, marble mantels, pocket doors, and hand-carved banisters—blend seamlessly with modern upgrades such as central air, updated plumbing and electrical systems, new windows and floors, a new boiler and flue, and LED lighting throughout.
The unfinished basement adds tremendous potential for a gym, recreation room, studio, or complete lower-level buildout. The deep lot even allows for the possibility of underpinning the yard to create an exceptionally expansive space.

The garden level offers a chef’s kitchen with Thermador appliances, marble countertops, and space for a large island with seating and a second dishwasher. This level also includes a spacious dining room, laundry facilities, and direct access to the sunny west-facing backyard.

The parlor level features a grand double parlor with a wood-burning fireplace, original shutters and wainscoting, and plumbing for a wet bar, plus a half bath overlooking the garden.

The upper floors boast an oversized primary bedroom, four additional light-filled bedrooms, generous walk-in California Closets, and two full baths—one featuring a deep soaking tub and bidet.
Every floor spans 900 square feet. With 400 square feet of additional FAR available and the ability to extend on the garden or roof level, this landmarked home offers rare architectural integrity, exceptional natural light, and meaningful expansion opportunities—all in one of Brooklyn’s most dynamic and convenient neighborhoods.